Beyond Unipolar: Why Some Depressions Are Actually Bipolar
Millions of people are diagnosed with major depressive disorder (MDD) every year—but what if a significant number of them actually have undiagnosed bipolar disorder? Research increasingly shows that many individuals who experience depression aren’t truly “unipolar.” Instead, they fall somewhere on the bipolar spectrum—a broader, more nuanced understanding of mood disorders that psychiatry is finally beginning to acknowledge.
In this post, we’ll explore why bipolar disorder is often mistaken for depression, how to spot the subtle signs that may point to a bipolar spectrum condition, and why getting the diagnosis right makes all the difference.
The Bipolar Spectrum: A Wider Lens on Mood Disorders
When most people hear “bipolar disorder,” they think of dramatic mood swings—from euphoric highs to crushing lows. But in reality, bipolar disorder includes a range of presentations—many of which don’t look like textbook mania.
Psychiatrist Hagop Akiskal and colleagues proposed a bipolar spectrum model that includes:
Classic bipolar I and II
Variants like bipolar I½, II½, III, III½, and IV
Temperament-based vulnerabilities, like cyclothymia or hyperthymia
These presentations may lack full manic episodes but still involve periodic elevations in energy, irritability, creativity, impulsivity, or sleeplessness—symptoms often overlooked or misinterpreted.
Why Bipolar Is Often Misdiagnosed as Depression
People with bipolar disorder often first seek help during a depressive episode, especially since the elevated states can feel enjoyable, productive, or go unnoticed. This leads to a pattern of misdiagnosis:
Studies show that up to 40% of people diagnosed with depression may actually have bipolar disorder.
On average, people with bipolar disorder wait 7–10 years before receiving a correct diagnosis.
The risk of misdiagnosis is higher in individuals with soft spectrum features, where hypomania is subtle or brief.
The consequences of misdiagnosis are serious. Many people are prescribed antidepressants without mood stabilizers, which can:
Worsen mood cycling
Induce hypomania or mania
Trigger agitation, irritability, or suicidality
Delay access to mood stabilizing treatment
Clues That Depression Might Be Bipolar
If you or someone you know has been diagnosed with depression but treatment hasn’t worked—or symptoms feel unstable—here are signs that the depression might actually be bipolar in nature:
1. Early onset of depression
Especially before age 25, with multiple episodes.
2. Family history of bipolar disorder
Even distant relatives with bipolarity or chronic mood instability.
3. Antidepressant “activation”
Feeling suddenly energized, irritable, or impulsive after starting medication.
4. Short depressive episodes
Less than two weeks—but still intense or recurring.
5. Periods of elevated mood
Episodes of:
Needing less sleep
Talking more than usual
Feeling overly confident
Sudden bursts of energy or creativity
Even if they don’t last 4 days (the DSM’s hypomania threshold), these may still be significant.
6. Irritability and rage during “depression”
Mixed states are common in bipolar depression and are often misread as anxiety or trauma responses.
The Problem with the DSM Criteria
The current DSM-5 criteria for bipolar disorder require:
At least 4 days of hypomania (for bipolar II)
Clear impairment or hospitalization for mania (for bipolar I)
But these rules don’t capture people who have:
Shorter bursts of hypomania
Milder, non-impairing elevations in mood
Energy shifts that don’t disrupt work or relationships—but are still real
As a result, many people fall through the cracks. Akiskal argued that this rigid approach ignores clinical reality, and that mood disorders exist on a continuum, not in binary boxes.
Why the Right Diagnosis Matters
Identifying bipolar features in someone with depression isn’t just about semantics—it directly affects treatment and outcomes.
Proper diagnosis means:
Starting mood stabilizers early, such as lithium, lamotrigine, or atypical antipsychotics
Avoiding unnecessary or harmful antidepressants
Improving long-term functioning and mood stability
Reducing the risk of suicide, hospitalization, and treatment resistance
It also helps people understand themselves better—why their mood patterns don’t fit “normal depression,” why certain treatments haven’t helped, and what support they actually need.
Conclusion: Ask the Bigger Question
If you’ve been treated for depression but still feel misunderstood, unstable, or reactive to medication, you might not be unipolar at all. You might be on the bipolar spectrum—and recognizing that could be the turning point in your mental health journey.
The right diagnosis leads to the right treatment. And the right treatment can change everything.
Browse blog posts